The Washington Post used the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) to obtain one of the documents that formed the Espionage Act case against National Security Agency (NSA) whistleblower Thomas Drake. Former classification czar under G.W. Bush, J William Leonard, was slated to testify as a defense expert for Drake and called the case the most "deliberate and willful example of government officials improperly classifying a document," he had ever seen.
Leonard’s views, outlined in an affidavit, got some support with the release of a memo that formed part of the evidence against Drake.
The once "classified" document (scare quotes around "classified" as none of the information that formed the basis of the Espionage Act counts against Drake was actually properly classified) is now public. Ellen Nakashima of WaPo reported on innocuous information in the document that formed the basis of an Espionage Act charge against Drake for allegedly retaining the document improperly.
Steven Aftergood, director of the Project on Government Secrecy at the Federation of American Scientists, also received the declassified memo from the NSA and said its disclosure reinforced questions raised about the prosecution.
“It’s utterly innocuous and practically devoid of meaningful content,” he said of the memo in an interview. “The idea that someone risked decades of prison over this document is an indictment of the agency and its classification policy.”
Leonard echoed those concerns in an e-mail to WaPo:
Leonard, speaking generally, said the system for classifying information is “becoming dysfunctional” and “clearly lacks the ability to differentiate between trivial information and that which can truly damage our nation’s well-being.”
- The Real Dangers of the "Leak" Hysteria
- Obama’s ‘War on Intelligence Whistleblowers’ Analyzed In-Depth
- Foreign Journalists See Obama More Objectively Than American Journalists
- Whistleblowing (In the Public Interest) vs. Leaking ("Authorized" Leaks for Political Gain)
- How Many Innocent Deaths Are Acceptable to Kill A Terrorist?
- Whistleblowers Not the Same as Undie-Bomb Leaker
- NSA Circles the Wagons: Refuses to Return Whistleblowers' Computers Seized in 2007
- Spypocrisy: U.S. to Use Technology in Crackdowns on Dissent (in other countries)
- U.S. Filmmaker Laura Poitras Repeatedly Detained at Border: She Has Filmed Three of My NSA Clients